Advantages and disadvantages of popular audio formats

Advantages and disadvantages of popular audio formats

 Audio File Formats

In today’s music world, there are a large number of audio file formats that are often confusing to the unprepared user. To understand all this, to find out what they are and what they are used for, the presented review will help.

Audio formats

Types of audio formats

Today is the time when all music lovers, not to mention professional musicians and audio editors, need to understand concepts like audio file formats, bit rates, extensions, bit depth, sample rate and many others. to achieve high quality sound. Sound has gone digital, which means that it can be used for various purposes, eg for listening to evidence, for presentations, video dubbing. In fact, digital sound, like an image, is a collection of individual pixels, and the more there are, the better the sound image. This “pixelated” sound can be edited and processed.

An important role in evaluating the quality of audio formats and consequently sound quality is a parameter such as bit rate, which shows how many bits or kilobits it takes to record one second of sound. Low bit rates mean low quality sound, high bit rates mean high quality sound.

But for the storage and further use of audio in one form or another, audio formats are used – digital recordings of audio data. We can say that the format is a kind of container where the sound is stored. Virtually all audio formats can be divided into two broad categories: lossless compressed and lossy compressed.

No loss, no loss

To avoid as much as possible a decrease in sound quality during the compression of an audio file, special methods have been developed to store audio information, avoiding losses, which in fact can be compared with the file when the information is simply packed in a zip file, the size of which is noticeably smaller than the original data. Later, this data can be clearly restored on each bit. And the bitrate itself is not important for these files. These audio files are collectively called Lossless, Music As Is. These algorithms allow you to compress files two to three times. As a result, the size becomes quite large, but at the same time the original sound is preserved.

Digital audio formats

Digital Audio Formats

Now there are several formats, but a basic distinction is made between lossless and lossy formats and compressed or uncompressed formats. Lossy formats are always compressed, which means a reduction in required storage space, but at the expense of playback quality. Lossless compressed formats offer faithful playback with low memory requirements.

However, the savings are less than with lossy formats. Lossless and uncompressed formats offer true-to-original music reproduction, but require a comparatively large amount of storage space. In return, they sometimes support even higher resolutions than compressed formats.

digital audio formats

What are sample rates and bit depth?

When talking about the resolution of digital music, two numbers are often mentioned. For CD quality around 44.1 kHz and 16 bit. The first number is the sample rate of the file. Describes how often the computer or network player extracts a signal from the file and processes it. 44.1 kHz means that a certain amount of data is transmitted 44,100 times per second. This amount of data is described by the bit depth (also word depth), the second number.

At the quality described, 16 bits of data are transmitted 44,100 times per second. If you want to determine the actual amount of data per second, you need to multiply these two numbers and get 705,600 accordingly. Since this is a stereo file with 2 channels, this number should be taken twice.

With CD quality music, 1,411,200 bits per second or, for the sake of simplicity, 1,411.2 kilobits are transmitted. A good MP3 file only transmits 320 kbps, so it only contains about a third of the information on a CD. Compared to 192 kHz 24-bit files, even less.What is the difference between compressed and uncompressed formats?
Uncompressed formats like

WAV do not affect music in any way. Frequencies and information are stored exactly as they are read during encoding. Therefore, uncompressed formats require more storage space in the first place than compressed formats. However, compressed does not automatically mean lossy. Formats like Apple’s FLAC or ALAC save music losslessly as a WAV file. However, they pack existing data more neatly without removing any information, thus requiring less storage space. Normally, there should be no effects on music information.

Why aren’t MP3 files high fidelity?

The MP3 format was introduced in 1992. It was revolutionary for the time, because by encoding music in MPEG-Audio Layer III, the full name of the format, you could achieve file compression of at least 4: 1, usually even 10: 1, compared to the classic CD. . This is possible because encoding in MP3 format removes the parts of the original file that are considered the least useful.

You can never make an exact copy of a music file in MP3 format and you cannot add information that has been deleted. So there is no point in converting an MP3 back to a lossless format. The AAC format used by Apple also cuts information from the original file to save space during compression.

We speak here of lossy or in English also of “lossy”, in contrast to the formats without loss or “without loss”. Meanwhile, it doesn’t really make sense to use such formats anymore, as more storage space shouldn’t be a problem today, unlike in 1992. The sound quality of MP3s is also significantly lower than that of other formats, as only 320 kbps is transmitted here at best, usually only 192 kbps or 256 kbps.

What is metadata?

Metadata are files attached to a file that contain additional information. In the case of digital music, these typically include things like sample rate, bit depth, and file format. In the best case, information about the song title, artist, album, composer, track number, etc. is also attached to the file. Modern streaming clients display this information when they play games on their screen or in an app. Also, these hidden attachments are often responsible for how the music in memory is organized.

Differences between digital audio formats (MP3, AAC, FLAC, WAV files, etc.)

Differences between digital audio formats (MP3, AAC, FLAC, WAV files, etc.)

What are the main digital audio formats and what are the differences between WAV, MP3, AAC, FLAC and others?

audio file formats

Differences in audio files To discover all types of digital audio formats, you must first understand briefly and synthetically what digital audio means and how it was created.

It all starts with Pulse Code Modulation (PCM), the basis for digital audio, which was founded in 1937 and is characterized by two properties: sampling rate for measuring the waveform amplitude and bit depth for measuring possible digital values.

If the sound is continuous in the real world, this is not the case in the digital world.

To understand the difference, you can think of digital videos that consist of still images that change quickly and give the impression of continuous motion.

It is the same for audio and the amplitude of the sound waves in a digital format is not fluid, but changes according to certain criteria at predefined intervals.

Since I am not an audio technician or physicist to do simple things and understand what digital audio is, I have found a very explanatory analogy that I am trying to explain here.

The analog audio source can be thought of as the water flowing from an open tap and the amplitude of the audio waveform as the water temperature.

Sampling can be viewed as the frequency with which the finger is immersed in the flowing water per second

The more the finger is immersed in it, the more continuous the temperature changes become.

audio formats

If you put your finger in the running water 44,100 times per second, it’s almost like holding your finger still all the time.

This is the idea behind the sampling rate.

In terms of bit depth, we should think that we’re using a thermometer instead of the finger.

If the water temperature is higher than that of the surrounding area, we will say that it is hot, otherwise it will be cold if it is below it.

Instead of only 2 options, we could mark 16 possible values ​​for measuring the water temperature.

The bit depth can be viewed as the number of values ​​with which the thermometer is to be used to measure the temperature. The more they are, the more accurate information is obtained.

Without losing ourselves technically, we are now seeing the most important digital audio file formats and their differences.

1) WAV and AIFF are lossless (i.e. uncompressed) PCM-based audio container formats with some minor changes in data storage.

.WAV or Wave is the standard format when you take a CD out of your computer (CD ripping).

A WAV and an AIFF can be converted into each other without changing the quality.

These audio formats are suitable for a stereo system (2 channels), they are sampled at 44.1 kHz (or 44100 times per second) with 16 bits (“CD quality”) and the files are approximately 10 MB per minute.

2) Lossless formats: FLAC (Free Lossless Audio Codec), ALAC (Apple Lossless Audio Codec) and APE

These formats compress audio using algorithms.

The difference between compressed files and FLAC files is that FLAC is specifically designed for audio and therefore has better compression rates without data loss.

As a rule, a .FLAC takes up half of the storage space of a WAV in megabytes and maintains the “CD quality”.

A FLAC can be converted to WAV without loss of quality and is the preferred format for those who want to listen to music with the best quality and great speakers.

3) Loss formats: MP3, AAC, WMA, Vorbis

.MP3 and .AAC files are the most common formats when you need to store music on a computer or phone and need to share or download music on the network and the Internet.

MP3 is a highly compressed “lossy” format that sacrifices a certain amount of audio quality for a significant gain in file size.

An MP3 has a size of approximately 1 MB per minute.

The difference to lossless formats is that if you convert the file to a less compressed format like WAV, the quality sacrificed during compression will not be restored.

The various lossy formats use different data storage algorithms, so they vary the size of the files with the same quality. For lossy formats such as MP3, the audio quality is measured using the bit rate value, which is generally specified in “192 kbit / s” or “192 kbit / s”.

The higher the bit rate, the more detailed the sound becomes.

Lossy and Lossy Digital Audio Formats: Audio Codec Guide

Lossy and Lossy Digital Audio Formats: Audio Codec Guide

In recent years, the way we listen to music has changed a lot, also thanks to the Internet, which has allowed a great diffusion of digital audio files. In a short time we went from vinyl to CD, to online music transmitted in high resolution.

losselless

An analog sound to be handled by a computer must become digital. To maintain the exact fidelity of the original audio, you must write a lot of information, thus producing heavy files that take up a lot of disk space. Hence the need to reduce the size of the audio file to save space on various storage media, such as hard drives, but also to take better advantage of the available bandwidth for transferring and listening to files.

Digital audio formats

Every day we use multimedia content such as YouTube, online radio or music streaming services, with a quality that is sometimes enough, other times excellent. This is because the files are the result of a data compression process through the use of codecs.

audio file formats

What is an audio codec?

A codec is an algorithm for encoding and decoding the audio (but also video) data stream.
It is used both to compress a file and to convert, for example, an analog to digital file. The difference in digital audio formats lies in the type of compression that determines their quality and, consequently, their size according to the type of codec used.

Types of digital audio formats.

Audio formats can be of three types:

-Loss (with data loss)
-No loss (no data loss)
-Uncompressed

Lossy digital audio formats

Lossy audio formats are compressed files with lost data and information. They allow you to significantly reduce the size of the original file, even up to 90%. The sound quality is lower than the CD-Audio standard because the compression algorithm “cuts” certain frequencies that the human ear has more difficulty perceiving and, therefore, are less relevant, generally the highest (more than 16 -17,000 Hz).

The Lossy audio format is widely used for listening to digital audio, such as streaming (Spotify, Deezer, Apple Music, etc.). Depending on the type of codec used, compression can vary significantly, as does the quality of the listening. The most popular and popular format is MP3 and WMA.

MP3

The most famous and well-known digital audio format. In its entirety, Motion Picture Expert Group-1/2 Audio Layer, 3, developed by MPEG, offers good compression and discrete audio quality, in particular with a bit rate of 192 kbit / s and 320 kbit / s. Although still widely used, better compression algorithms can be found.

OGG Vorbis

The open source format without lossy audio compression offers an excellent alternative to MP3. With the same perceived quality, it allows for greater compression. The high frequencies (above 16 kHz) are wider and wider, offering greater spatiality of sound. Also used in computer games, it is also often used for audio streaming. Spotify music, for example, uses the Ogg Vorbis digital audio format from 96 kbit / s to 320 kbit / s in addition to the AAC codec.

WMA

Windows Media Audio is Microsoft’s proprietary digital audio format. Encrypted WMA offers excellent compression and good audio quality at high bit rates, but at the same time little compatibility. Precisely for this feature it is now little used. WMA consists of four different codecs: WMA codec, lossless WMA (lossless), WMA Pro, or WMA Voice.

AAC

The Advanced Audio Coding Format (AAC) is part of the MPEG consortium and was born as MP3’s successor. It became famous thanks to Apple that uses it with iTunes, but also thanks to several radios (DABè) that use it to transmit audio. It is the excellent quality and good compression digital audio format used by YouTube, iPhone, Android smartphones and many other devices such as Nintendo and Playstation. The AAC supports 48 audio channels with sampling up to 96 kHz and uses constant bit rate (CBR – Constant Bit Rate) or variable (VBR – Variable Bit Rate) compression encoding. AAC is one of the best lossy codecs, the encoding speed is not among the best.

MPC

Musepack (or MPC) together with AAC vies for the podium as the best lossy digital audio format. The quality is very high, thanks to the VBR encoding that guarantees a good distribution of the bit rate. The peculiarity of this codec, in terms of AAC, is the clarity of the sound, which is very wide and spacious. Good encoding speed, it is ideal for those looking for quality while keeping a small audio file size.

ATTRAC

ATRAC (Adaptive Transform Acoustic Coding) is a lossy audio compression algorithm developed by Sony. Born for MiniDisc (MD) whose production ended in 2013, this codec has not been very successful and is no longer used today.

mP3Pro

Derived from MP3, its peculiarity lies in the fact that it maintains the same quality as an MP3 at 128 kbps but with lower bit rates, from 64 kbps to a maximum of 96 kbps. Compression of the higher frequencies, a painful note from lossy files, occurs through the Spectral Band Replication (SBR) algorithm. The result is space savings at lower bit rates, but also less dynamic and unclear sound.

Dolby Digital

Dolby Digital is a multi-channel audio encoding system, used primarily in DVD, film, and digital television. Contrary to what one might think, it is a lossy audio format, therefore compressed with loss of information. Known as Dolby Digitale 5.1, it works with a minimum bit rate of 96 kbit / s up to a maximum of 640 kbit / s. On DVD, it maintains an average of 192 kbit / s in stereo audio and up to 448 kbit / s in 5.1 signals

Lossless digital audio formats

Lossless audio formats are compressed but lossless files. They maintain the original audio quality, without degrading its characteristics in any way, while managing to compress certain information up to 40-50%. The most popular and widely used Lossless Codec format is the FLAC (Free Lossless Audio Codec) file. Apple has produced its own lossless format called ALAC (Apple’s Lossless Audio Codec) that iTunes uses.

Lossless files offer the quality of a CD (reported as standard), but to maintain fidelity, the dimensions will be larger and take up more disk space than Lossy, but still half the original file.

FLAC

FLAC (Free Lossless Audio Codec) is a codec released under a free software license with lossless data compression. Extended and compatible with most audio devices, the FLAC codec compresses data from a minimum of 30% to 50%, compared to the original file, while maintaining the perceived quality unchanged.
A Flac file can be 8, 16, or 24-bit deep and has a sample rate of up to 192 kHz (Flac Hi-Res).
Various music audio streaming services like Deezer Music, QoBuz, Tidal offer high quality music equal to or higher than the CD standard using this format.

Lossless wma

WMA Lossless is the lossless version of Microsoft’s WMA Lossy codec. It offers good and fast compression. Although it is proprietary, it can also be played by VLC Media Player, WinaAmp, RealPlayer and others.

A THE C

ALAC (Apple Lossless Audio Codec), also known as ALE (Apple Lossless Encoder) is an audio codec developed by Apple in 2004. In 2011, the source code was made available under an open source license. Primarily used by iTunes, other online music services have also used it in recent years. Excellent audio quality and fast decoding, but slightly less compression than FLAC files.