MP3 vs M4A, the most complete comparison

MP3 vs M4A, the most complete comparison

M4A vs MP3

If you like listening to digital music, chances are you are familiar with different types of audio files. Now let’s talk about them and try to distinguish between the two most popular audio files today: MP3 and M4A.

mp3 vs m4a

Compare mp3 vs m4a

Here is the difference between MP3 and M4A:

So M4A is a compressed audio file with MPEG-4 technology, which has a lossy compression algorithm. It is mainly associated with “MPEG-4 Audio Layer” and the files of this extension are organized in audio layers of MPEG-4 movies (without video). Its goal is to surpass MP3 and become the new standard for audio compression. M4A is quite similar to MP3, but it is designed to have better quality at the same or even smaller file size. The M4A format was first introduced by Apple. The format type is also known as an Apple Lossless Encoder (ALE). Apple iTunes Store is the dominant force in digital music distribution.

How to play M4A

MPEG-4 video and audio files generally use the .mp4 file extension, but when it is for audio only, the file generally has the .m4a extension.

The use of the M4A format can be seen more frequently on devices that work with the Apple ecosystem (iOS, macOS), as well as on the Windows platform (developed by Microsoft) (M4A) it is easily used by users (despite the great popularity of MP3).

Because it will be useful to the user to be able to play almost all popular media files locally. For example, from a set of audio and video formats: MP4, FLV, MP3, MPG, SWF, DIVX, MOV, MKV, WMV, DAT, FLAC, AVI, M4V, and other formats are also supported.

However, going back to the format comparison, to date, M4A has yet to recapture the main success of MP3, as the audio format is not yet universally played. It is limited to PC, iPod and other Apple products only.

Convert MP3 to M4A On the other hand, MP3 is the most popular digital audio format. MP3 was also one of the first compression formats and has become extremely popular with music lovers / collectors. Its main success is so overwhelming that the file type can be anywhere and play with “near empty” hardware or software. Information for those interested in how to convert MP3 to M4A is as follows. In theory, M4A will reproduce better sound quality, but many argue that regardless of whether this is true or not, the sound difference is not distinguishable and it would be a waste of time trying to convert MP3 files to M4A files. In the end, changing will only contribute to the loss of the original sound quality, so it’s not a good idea if you don’t need to change it.

What is the best audio format? Most enthusiasts would recommend that when choosing a format, the player and the ears should be considered primarily. If you have an iPod and you mainly listen to music through it, then aim for the M4A. In fact, portability and convenience are a major and urgent concern, as the difference in sound quality is almost imperceptible if you are actually working on highly technical material.

Summary of the comparison between M4A and MP3:

1. Obviously, MP3 is still the most popular audio format, including the lesser known M4A.

2. M4A is designed to have better sound quality in less space than MP3.

3. Mp3 differs in that the file can be played anywhere, with almost any playback device, whereas M4A has yet to reach these heights.

4. MP3 was released first and M4A was partially designed to dethrone MP3 like most popular audio formats.

5. Actually, M4A is only for Mpeg-4 file audio compression.

m4a, characteristics of the m4a format

The M4A format is short for MPEG-4 part 14 and is a type of file created by Apple in 2004 from the QuickTime file format. It is a digital media container used to store audio components, but it can also contain other data (for example, images). The M4A is a file extension for an audio file encoded with Advanced Audio Encryption (AAC) which is lossy compression. M4A was generally intended as the successor to MP3, which was not originally designed for audio only, but was layer III in an MPEG 1 or 2 video file.

M4A Files Technical Details

M4A files are an improvement over MP3 files, basically due to their ability to offer lossless compression versus lossy compression from their competition. Files can be converted over and over from / to original audio and size. MP4 copying is restricted by DRM technology, but the M4A file type is easy to copy and distribute. For this reason, Apple uses M4A files for the sale of audio and the transfer of content to CDs and mobile music players. Being a strictly Apple product, it can be difficult to use these files in Windows, but iTunes for Windows makes it possible, as well as converting these files to Windows compatible audio formats (which involve lossy compression).

Developing

M4A files, are a type of audio files developed and popularized by Apple, since 2007 the songs purchased through the iTunes store have been in m4a format, therefore there are more than 15 billion files worldwide, MP4 and M4A files are usually confused and the two are quite similar, both are based on the MPEG-4 codec, however M4A is a file that only contains audio while the MP4 can also contain video.

What is the MP4 format?

Contrary to MP3 format, MP4 is not a video format as such, but it is a container that houses an audio track and a video track that can be encoded in different codecs.

MP4 is short for MPEG-4 Part 14, and is based on the specifications of the MOV video format, developed by Apple.

Because MP4 is a container format, its component parts, audio and video, can be encoded in different formats, which can be adapted to the implementation of the resulting file.

Generally these formats are, for AAC audio and H264 MPEG 4 video, both formats with an excellent compression / quality ratio, which allows MP4 files to be transmitted over the Internet without difficulties.

Due to the characteristics of the MP4, acronym of the English name Motion Picture Experts Group-4, in this type of container it is possible to include inside for example a complete film in high quality, which is also possible to do in a storage space really reduced.

What is the M4A format?

M4A is an extension used to represent a compressed audio file in an MPEG-4 container. The standard file name extension defined by MPEG-4 is MP4 that covers both audio and video but MPEG-4 files that contain only audio typically carry an M4A extension. Actually, this file format was not very popular until Apple Inc. first used it on iTunes and iPod for songs using either Advanced Audio Coding (AAC) or Apple Lossless (ALAC) codecs to differentiate it from other audio files. MPEG-4 since 2007.

M4A

Extension: M4A (MPEG-4 audio)

Category: Audio File

Popularity: Among Apple users

Developer: Apple Inc.

Facts about M4A

M4A audio files are not protected. Protected files usually have an M4P extension.
The audio in M4A can be decoded back to the original quality it had before compression.
Most songs on M4A in the iTunes Store are paid but there are also special offers and gifts from time to time.
The iTunes Store also supplies music in formats other than M4A.
A song in M4A can be set directly as a ringtone on an iPhone simply by changing the file extension from M4A to M4R with iTunes.
It is a codec designed to provide coding without loss of quality that takes up little space.
Pros: The file in M4A format is compressed, but without loss of quality. Also in favor that M4A has no DRM (Digital Rights Management) protection and therefore can be edited and transferred with greater freedom.

Cons: M4A has no recognition problems on iTunes, iPod and other Apple devices, but its poor compatibility with other devices makes playback of M4A files not as comfortable as MP3 files.

M4A vs MP3

In general M4A is considered the successor of MP3 because it does the same as this but compared to MP3, the M4A can compress audio at the same bit rate in a smaller file. M4A files usually have a stereo bit rate of 128kbps, 192kbps or 256kbps. (By the way, bit rate refers to the amount of information that is transmitted within a given amount of time through a digital network. The common way to measure the bit rate is in kbits / s and Mbps, that is kilobytes and megabytes per second. In general, it doesn’t matter which unit you use, the higher the number, the higher the speed or the better quality). If you are familiar with music coding, it is advisable to save the music in M4A at 192kbps so that we can obtain high quality and a manageable file. For more information, see the comparison below.

Quality: For obvious reasons an M4A file with ALAC compression has the best quality since nothing of the original audio signal will be lost. And even for a file encoded with AAC compression with losses, tests indicate that it still gives better sound quality than MP3 files encoded at the same bit rates, especially when the bit rate is equal to or less than 128kbps.

File size: The size of the file and its quality are directly related to the bit rate. When it goes up, it will also increase the sound quality as well as the file size. For example, to obtain the same quality, an MP3 song needs to be encoded around 192kbps, while one in M4A is enough with 128kbps, which translates into a smaller file size.

Compatibility: Without a doubt, MP3 is still the norm in the audio industry. Almost all software and hardware is compatible with it. Instead, M4A files can only be read on PC, iPod, iTunes and other Apple devices.